Dry stone wailing
Hope everyone likes the new font. I will try to write (or at least format) in more bite-sized chunks. And expect photographs of more photogenic people than me soon.
Now, I was going to use this post to write about how writers feel when they read stuff by other writers, but instead I am going to confess to a killing.
It’s true. It was the early hours of Saturday morning. The silent study of an old house, a small country town, only me and the victim awake. It was quick, and almost silent, but it was not without a struggle.
Yes, I’ve got ink on my hands. I’ve murdered nine thousand of my darlings.
Specifically, nine thousand words of my novel. Deleted. Elided. Cut out and cast away. Nine thousand words which, through no fault of their own, took a wrong turn two or three months back and ended up in a very bad place - a dead end.
I’m shovelling the dirt into the shallow grave as we speak.
Nine thousand freaking words. Two bloody months.
But I had to do it. I have a character called Wulfric. He’s fairly important. When I first pictured him he was an oblate, a novice monk. I liked the idea of someone who would choose that kind of life. I liked the idea of mediaeval monasteries, the way they were part library, part school, part spiritual power station, the way the monks were seen as soldiers and the monasteries vast fortified towers in a war against things we don’t even beleive in anymore. I needed a male intellectual in my party to balance out my increasingly remarkable heroine.
So we had Wulfric. He turns up in chapter two. By chapter five I’ve got him and his mentor riding up to the gates of Saint Walpurg’s so that he can apply to enter the monastery.
And… it’s… all… been… crap.
It does not work. It will not fly (or ride, or walk, or whatever). There is no reason why the kind of person he has turned out to be would do this.
He’s young.
He’s just fallen in love with someone who despises him.
He’s urbane.
He loves life and learning.
His mentor (Echthstan* - see below) is returning to Rhiem, the city Wulfric loves most - Wulfric is expected to go with him, he has passage booked to France.
His only previous experience of monastic life was the three horrible months after his parents died, before Echthstan came and saved him.
He has problems, but I cannot see how he could see that any of them would be solved by a lifetime vow of poverty, chastity and obedience, by abstinence and seclusion in a strange land.
But narrative inertia or plotline fundamentalism or whatever is a terrible thing. You set your eyes on a location, like a distant mountaintop, and you set out, and you trudge on and on, never letting your eye wander, never seeing the new paths that have opened up around you, never thinking there are other places you could go, never even noticing how the very ground has altered beneath your feet.
Late Friday night I looked at Wulfric, lying on a narrow pallet in Walpurg’s, tonsured and tortured, fevered and alone, wasted with what they call Stranger’s Fever. A small-framed monk with bright green eyes sat by his bed and asked him what the hell he was doing there.
And I realised I had no remotely believable answers.
So - nine thousand words back into the aether. Because if I want my book to have a plot where people act like human beings would actually act - and try and get themselves in and out of situations in ways that would benefit themselves and what they believe in, rather than proceed as previously arranged - then it’s got to be this way.
The good thing is I know it’s not wasted effort**.
And I know a lot of other people have written off more - entire novels and so forth.
And I know I’m a lot further forward today now I’ve made that decision than if I had kept grinding mindlessly on, trying to herd my characters past a pre-arranged series of plot points like sheep.
(Maybe that sounds like a cliche. I want something that gives the same sense of external control, of harried mindlessness. Maybe I should change “sheep” to lemmings.
Or maybe robots.
Say robot lemming-sheep.
Yes, herded like robot lemming-sheep.
Much better.)
Sigh. Nine thousand words.
Anyhow. Time to ring up my “suspiciously alarming and resourceful in these kind of matters” mate for an alibi. From what I now recall, I was with him at the time. Funeral on Friday, wreaths and donations to the “Writers Who Will Maybe Face Facts A Little Sooner Next Time” Foundation.
Thanks for listening,
BDC
* Note to those considering setting any work of fiction in 990 AD England. Choose carefully. Many of the names are frankly indigestible, and pretty soon you end up with characters called Echthstan, Wuffa, Odo and Grychthnych. Plus you also have to work out what to do with Saint Sexburga.
** It’s what we used to call in medicine a VLE, or valuable learning experience. Of course, it differs from the traditional medical VLE, which was you standing looking pale and miserable, the consultant jabbing his/her finger at something in the notes, and in the background the resuscitation entering its fortieth minute.